Two Pens in Paris: Hemingway and Fitzgerald

In 1920s Paris, one man had already tasted fame and the other was chasing it — and their friendship would help define a literary generation.

Rivals & Friendships · 3 min read ·

Two Pens in Paris: Hemingway and Fitzgerald
Nickolas Muray, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

By the time Ernest Hemingway arrived in Paris in the 1920s, F. Scott Fitzgerald was already a celebrated name in American letters. His 1920 novel This Side of Paradise had made him a sensation, and its commercial success had even persuaded Zelda Sayre's family to finally approve their marriage. Fitzgerald and Zelda married, and in 1921 their only child was born. But it was in the cafés and salons of Paris that Fitzgerald's story intertwined with Hemingway's.

Fitzgerald traveled frequently to Paris during this decade, drawn into the orbit of the modernist writers and artists who would later be called the 'Lost Generation.' Among the American literary expatriates he befriended there, none would loom larger in his life and legacy than Ernest Hemingway, then an emerging voice in American fiction.

Their friendship, however, existed alongside real strain. Hemingway never got along well with Zelda. In his view, she distracted her husband, encouraged his heavy drinking, and interfered with his ability to write. This tension between the two men closest to Fitzgerald — his wife and his fellow writer — shadowed their relationship even as it endured.

Fitzgerald's second novel, The Beautiful and Damned (1922), pushed him further into the cultural elite of the era, while he continued to churn out stories for magazines like The Saturday Evening Post to support his and Zelda's lavish lifestyle. His most enduring work, The Great Gatsby, followed in 1925 — a novel that drew on his own preoccupations with fame, wealth, and his complicated marriage to Zelda. Despite its now-legendary status, Gatsby sold fewer than 23,000 copies in its first year and received only mixed acclaim in its time.

As the 1920s wore on, cracks widened. Zelda's mental health deteriorated, and she was eventually diagnosed with schizophrenia and placed in an institution. Fitzgerald wrote Tender Is the Night (1934) in the wake of this crisis, but neither that novel nor Gatsby earned him the critical or commercial triumph he had hoped for. Financial pressure mounted, worsened by the Great Depression's toll on his magazine income.