The Angel's Wing and the Young Master's Eye

Long mistaken for another painter's work, this quiet garden scene turned out to hold the first fingerprints of a genius. Look closely at the angel's wings — someone later couldn't resist making them bigger.

Works of Art · 3 min read ·

The Angel's Wing and the Young Master's Eye
Leonardo da Vinci, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

In a Florentine workshop sometime between 1472 and 1476, a young apprentice named Leonardo da Vinci painted his earliest surviving major work. He was training under Andrea del Verrocchio, and the painting he produced — oil and tempera on a broad poplar panel — took up a subject every Florentine artist of the century seemed drawn to: the Annunciation, the moment the angel Gabriel tells Mary she will bear a son named Jesus, the 'Son of God,' whose reign would never end.

The scene follows Luke's gospel, but Leonardo set it apart from the many other versions Florentine painters had produced, including several by Fra Angelico. He placed Mary and Gabriel in an open courtyard, with a sweeping Tuscan landscape and seascape stretching behind them. He used chiaroscuro to soften the figures' forms, letting light and shadow do the work later generations would call sfumato. The architecture obeys the strict rules of linear perspective, converging toward a central vanishing point — though scholars have noted odd touches, like Mary's oddly extended right arm, possibly a trace of Leonardo's early interest in optics and how the painting would have been seen from a side altar.

The details reward close looking. The marble table before Mary likely echoes the tomb of Piero and Giovanni de' Medici in the Basilica of San Lorenzo, a work Verrocchio himself was sculpting around that time. A gauzy, semi-transparent veil covers the book of scripture Mary is reading, a nod to the prophecies of the Old Testament. The Latin letters on the page, drawn from a medieval scribal lexicon, spell nothing in particular — Mary seems to be absorbed less in reading than in contemplating the very shapes of the letters, a mystical mode of spiritual attention. Gabriel holds a Madonna lily, symbol of both Mary's virginity and the city of Florence itself.

Leonardo, ever the observer of nature, is thought to have painted Gabriel's wings after the wings of a real bird in flight. Later, though, another hand lengthened them dramatically, altering the angel's silhouette from what the young Leonardo had intended.

Who actually commissioned the piece remains uncertain. The painting eventually surfaced at the Olivetan monastery of San Bartolomeo near Florence, leading scholars to guess that the monks there may have ordered it for their sacristy following the church's renovation in 1472.